At 3:16 MacArthur quotes N.T. Wright but conveniently leaves
out some extremely important clarification ***at the center of the quote***. Here is the actual quote in full:
“I must stress again that the doctrine of justification by faith is
not what Paul means by ‘the gospel’. It is implied by the gospel; when the
gospel is proclaimed, people come to faith and so are regarded by God as
members of his people. But ‘the gospel’ is not an account of how people get
saved.”
—N.T. Wright, What Saint Paul Really Said, pp. 132–33
—N.T. Wright, What Saint Paul Really Said, pp. 132–33
Now I’ve read this book and many others by Wright and listened
to dozens of his lectures. I know exactly what Wright believes the Gospel to be
and how he believes it saves. I also understood how even the edited quote given
by MacArthur doesn’t contradict 1 Corinthians 15:1-2. But by leaving out Wright’s
very important clarification, MacArthur mischaracterizes the argument for those
unfamiliar with Wright. MacArthur is either being blatantly dishonest or profoundly
ignorant. Given that he freely admits that he doesn’t understand Wright I will
go with the option that MacArthur is profoundly ignorant of Wright’s theology.
Again, quite fine to critique Wright’s work (I do so on his
views of penal substitution and the intermediate state), but before MacArthur
gets into the pew and publicly criticizes Wright he better understand what he’s
talking about.
No comments:
Post a Comment